The fact that you can kinda hold a frame lock closed is an argument for it being better, but they seem to be just as prone to failing if not more so than liner locks. Regarding the Strider lockup geometries, I have both old and new. Yes, the lock is narrow at the bend point, but if I reach the point if breaking that, I'm seriously misusing the knife. I have a Kingdom Armory Ti framelock on the way, I believe its lockup is similar to that of the CRK. They have actually switched over to a less aggressive interface in the last two years. The tension slips the bar inward to create the contact with the blade’s butt and keep it firmly and prevent it from closing when the knife fully opened. It is seen in a lot of mid to upper range knives and made from titanium. Lock Strength. I came across this video today, and it sums up the argument of whether frame locks or liner locks are better. Your email address will not be published. If you like the lock with lighter weight and not having to touch a lot of metal as well as adding grip, you should choose the liner lock. Because of their similarity to liner locks, closing a frame lock knife is virtually the same — push down on the spring bar so it no longer blocks the butt of the blade, remove your thumb from the path, then fold the knife closed. 11:04 . They look similar but in fact, they have a lot of differences. Its frustrating to read some comments of people saying "how" a knife would fail. You can close the knife by one hand with no switching grip which is ideal for the case that you need with hands on doing the job. I may have only spent $20 on my buck nobleman, but It has served me really well (despite the way I beat it up, which is the point of a $20 frame lock/liner lock knife) and I think it gets the lock really right. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. The heavy-duty roof truss system, manufactured for extreme conditions. I believe that after reading my article, you will discover the benefit of having knife lock and consider if the lock type is your option or not. Classy Appearance: Satin Finish Blade Has A Modern Look | Strong And Lightweight: Aluminum Handle Combines Strength With Minimal Weight | Easy Maintenance: Field Strip Take Apart Your Knife For Cleaning Without Tools Honestly I cannot stand frame locks as they always feel awkward but I know this is an expense of the added strength. Better than my previous, non-locking SAKs. Assuming you didn't just buy a custom, my Mini-Sam came with an insane amount of side to side play and lock rock. Instead the lock just slips. You can close the knife by one hand with no switching grip which is ideal for the case that you need with hands on doing the job. Residual limb length, lifestyle, and hand strength can determine the suspension method best suited for an amputee’s prosthesis. Strength of Byrd Knife Liner Locks? Before I get into this I just want to say that lock strength doesn't really matter for most of us, and this is just more of a curiosity for me than anything else. However, the liner lock is not squeezed due to the protection of the slabs. I sent it back to David and now I have a knife that locks up like a custom knife and is so smooth you can't believe it. You can see that the engagement point is almost completely flat and the entire width of the blade, fitting in with no wobble. The Alpha SmartTemp Silicone Liner absorbs and stores heat as it builds up in a residual limb delaying the onset of sweat before it starts. The liner lock is the type of lock that can attract both of knife beginner and professional. However, when you use it, you will see a lot of distinguishing things between them. Blade HQ 482,477 views. When the tang clears, it snaps underneath it and prevents the blade from coming forward. Locking; Suction Sleeves; Suction; Suspension Aids; Feet. I believe the old, radiused lock up was intended to resist failures in crappy conditions (wet, muddy, dirty, hard use, whatever), and the new lockup was mainly to reduce instances of lock rock that cropped up in some of the older knives - correct me if I'm wrong. While I agree with you about the failure videos not representing real world use. Pocket knives are the necessary item for every day using, and it is convenient to carry. I agree with what you're saying about the interface between the tang and the lock bar being the most important part. Thus, it is lighter than the other lock. The handle can prevent over extension. My SMF (old) locks up like a vault exactly this much, while my SNG (new) locks up so early I'd kind of like it to settle in a bit more. Which to me means that it isn't the thinness of the lock cut out, or where it is position, how thick the arm is, or the percentage of lock up (Though later is usually better). To lose the liner lock, you need to use your thumb finger to push the spring bar down so that it can clear contact from the blade’s butt. It's the fitting that matters. Some people said that the frame one is simpler which is nice but you sacrifice some features inherent in the liner one. The most different point between them is the locking mechanism. The Gun Geek 14,338 views. Required fields are marked *. The Boy Scout manual will tell you that, if you use the knife properly and safely, as the tool is designed, you shouldn't need a lock. And if you have to the lock should beer be engaged. Frame lock can not be confused with the list of common knife lock. • Patented Triple Lock® design for strength • Right sized packaging to lower shipping costs • Best available materials/alloys • 40+ years of manufacturing experience • “Immediate” availability (24–72 hour lead time) • Listed by Underwriters Laboratories 1777 635. Viewer Inquiry: Frame Lock vs Liner Lock? New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. The first major function of the frame lock is that the handle’s portion moves to lock the blade tag. It's up way past the lock in Nutella, peanut butter, gravel/sand/mud (got dropped in three lakes) and it always just cleans right out. The AQUALINER® Fresh, the only antimicrobial tank liner in the world. Chances are if used in a specific way, any knife will fail. It allows using your index to push the blade enough. It seems to be the version of the liner lock. Developed and patented by Spyderco, it provides extreme lock strength and ease of use. Thus, you can take your thumb out from the blade path and go on to close your knife safely. There are both of entry level and high-end level knife on liner lock. However, we have scale without the liner. The problem I noticed is that most of the thoughts on the subject are concerned with the lock actually breaking, but most failures in liner locks and frame locks don't usually involve (Though it has happened) anything breaking. 5 years ago. An alternative to r/knives. No more pennies, dimes and quarters in your swimming pool coping! Trying to find out the information about the products and the suggestion of those who have experience in using this type to have the total view of the lock. The reason is that it made from the thinner piece of metal, it is more prone to wear out compared to the frame lock. The liner using less metal, so the price is lower than the frame one. Nothing actually broke. The one handed ease of operation of the compression lock has become the bane of existence of many a knife nut’s spouse – from anecdotal evidence. Beaded liner lock strip replaces everything you have used in the past to try to keep your pool liner locked into place. So my assumption is that the strength of both the liner lock and frame lock depends on how the radius, shoulder, or what ever you call the geometry on the back of the tang that the lock face comes into contact with is done. The Alpha Duo Liner combines the comfort of gel with the durability of silicone. Fixings should be place at 150mm (depending on strength of wall) ALSO LINER LOCK FOR ABOVE GROUND POOLS Also available Liner lock coping strips for use on above ground pool over lap liner installations approximately 4ft long per strip Equipment & Accessories: Pool Liners: Products categories: Pools, Equipment & Accessories, In-ground: Brands: Plastica: Side mount liner lock. Thus, you should know what kind of lock you expect, type of lock may depend on your demands and preferences. Liner lock takes some getting used to if you grew up with the lock back style (a la Buck 110). A lock is a safety feature, I think strong locks are great, but people should always remember that if you expect to use a knife in a fashion that could compromise the locking blade, then you shouldn't be using a folding knife. That's the most important difference to me, because it's the practical difference. How that effects opening new knife boxes? A lock mechanism that uses a leaf-like spring from a split liner in the handle to wedge laterally between a ramp on the blade tang and the stop pin (or anvil pin). TL;DR: The debate between whether liner locks or frame locks is stronger seems to be focusing on the wrong thing. However, the frame lock is stronger than the liner lock since they use more mental on frame lock so more force from the frame. 6:50 . The Alpha Silicone AK Liner with symmetrical profile provides extra protection to the distal femur and allows the liner to be rotated for extended wear. 5. Emerson Roadhouse Muddy Spine whack Test - Duration: 1:56. It dosen't really matter which is better in theory it's all execution, a crappy cheap frame lock will fail under way less stress then a good frame lock like a zt350. The further below this line the spring would go, the stronger the lock up will be. This section of the frame lock is cut to engage the blade’s bottom under the pivot that prevents closing. I hope that you can get the useful information from my post. Interesting take. When you open the blade, you may see the left section of the handle is inward when the blade opens completely. Achetez CERBERUS Strength Heavy Duty Sandbag with Liner Kit - Built TOUGH - Quadruple Stitched - up to 130kg capacity by CERBERUS Strength: Amazon.fr Livraison & … This is a great post. Post by SpyderEdgeForever » Sun Mar 18, 2018 6:55 pm Regarding the liner locks used on the Byrd knife line: Can I rest assured that this lock will hold the blade open as long as I am not abusing it or putting too much unnecessary stress on it, and it will not snap closed and cut me? It is said that the frame lock is safer than the liner lock. The industry-leading 20–year conditional warranty on the tank and liner. 4. We can easily to see that the liner has the locking liner and the another scale, so the mechanism position of the liner is different from the frame lock. The … Batoning will put heaps of force on the spine, but it should only be done with fixed blades. Selecting a prosthetic foot can be a daunting task. It's an interesting take. Liner Lock Final Thoughts - Duration: 6:50. The liner stabilizes skin temperature to … In addition to increased strength and safety of operation over a liner lock, a compression lock also has a higher “fidget” factor than a liner lock, owing to its ability to be swung open when the lock is pushed open similarly to an Axis Lock. The strength of use liner lock is that it allows a knife to have two handle side, it is not the same with the frame lock. It's the way the lock interfaces with the blade tang it's self. Thus, it helps to ensure the strong lockup for slicing, cutting and some heavy duty tasks. In my page, I am going to show you two kind of knife lock which is the most popular nowadays. Fast Opening: IKBS ball bearing pivot deploys the blade fast | Fast Opening: The flipper deploys the blade fast | Strong And Lightweight: Aluminum handle combines strength with minimal weight | Designed by Ken Onion in Kaneohe, Hawaii | Limited Lifetime Warranty covers any defects in materials or workmanship, see company site for details So my assumption is that the strength of both the liner lock and frame lock depends on how the radius, shoulder, or what ever you call the geometry on the back of the tang that the lock face comes into contact with is done. Due to some of the similarity between them, pushing down on the spring bar, so it does not block the blade’s butt, take out your thumb finger before fold the knife closed. Frame lock knives tend to be stronger than liner locks, as the piece of metal that slips into place is more substantial than that in a liner. As long as a lock type is properly done, all are reliable. Feet. Choose a good manufacturer and this issue is pretty much moot. | Durable 8Cr13MoV stainless steel, clip point blade keeps its sharp edge and strength, is corrosion and wear resistant; features a top swedge and slight recurve to enhance slicing capabilities. Stop Police Terror (stoppoliceterror.com) is a participant in the amazon associates program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com. The PIONEER V-LOCK® tank wall profile provides the strength of corrugated steel and maintains support for the liner while minimizing stress. As I have told you before, the frame is stronger than the liner lock, because the piece of the metal which slipped into place is much more substantial than its line lock. 2. You can get a frame lock to fail by holding it in a reverse grip and twisting counter clockwise. All things pocket knives. The CRK lockup is like the new Strider lockface - gradually sloped surfaces, just much later. Excellent knife for strength work, strong reliable, flipper, which is very convenient, you can open with one hand, lock the liner at the beginning of the heel blade.Shave out of the box,blade is centered. To release the lock, you can easily push the lock back out of the way, and the blade tang will be released to allow you for folding. Press J to jump to the feed. I also don't think either a frame or liner lock is really truly a 'lock' they are basically just really strong levers that prop the blade open. Use this bead wedge lock to secure your beaded pool liner into the pool coping. Reset it and the lock works fine. - Duration: 11:49. My experience tells me that a flatter lower angle shoulder (`a la Sebenza) provides a more secure lock than something with a noticeable radius and more aggressive angle like how Strider use to do them. Both of two models share the same size, and it looks similar too. In conclusion, each type of lock has the different drawbacks and benefits. For this type of lock, the manufacturer puts a lot of portion of metal on the blade. You also have to remember that to test a locks strength you have to force the fucker until it fails. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Besides, I will make the comparison between them that will helps you to get easy in giving a decision. Functionally they're identical, but frames tend to be more robust and sturdy. They both follow the same concept. The spring bar is tight when the knife is closed. When you want to buy a knife, there are a lot of factors that you need to care, especially it locking mechanism which is one of the most important parts. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, KaBar D'Eskabar, BullDozier, Kershaw Skyline. If pure lock strength is your concern, neither liner or frame locks are best. The liners are lightweight, so it is easier than it may seem at first glance. I think how the Tang interfaces with the lock face is where these locks get most their strength. To provide a lock with maximum strength, the spring on the liner should engage the blade as far below the centre line of the pivot as possible. Liner Lock Strength Discussion in 'Emerson Knives' started by CQC86, Apr 24, 2010. What is annoying to me about this video is him making an immense amount of claims based on frame lock failures that have never even happened to him. Something like an axis, ball bearing or bolt action locks seem like they actually 'lock' the blade in position. CRK lockup is just right IMO. BSA Sweet 17 Scope Review: An In-Depth Analysis, Top Best Rifle Bipod Review 2019 for Hunting. A good, reliable knife in the hand is conveniently straight and reverse grip.Reduced fat, solid food breaks. The liner is suitable for transtibial and transfemoral applications. Knife, knife, collection knives, military knife, blade, sale, sports camping knife, craft knife, military knife and tactical knife collection, hunting knife, knife made in Italy, gentleman knife, training knife, rescue knife, fantasy knife, utility knife, knife, Locking Type Liner Lock, Stainless Steel ATS-34, Stainless Steel N690Co, Stainless Steel VG-10, Stainless Steel AUS-4 There are both of entry level and high-end level knife on liner lock. If you need to save a life by hammering on the spine of the blade keep the blade and handle at a 90 degree angle so you don't compromise the internal construction and only put stress on the blade itself. Liner lock is one of the most common locks which appears mostly on folding knives. I'm no physicist but it seems like the more surface area you have of the liner or frame against the tang, the better/more secure the lockup would be assuming it doesn't have a really weak point in the cutout. As Cliff pointed out in Episode 9, virtually all knives made today have locks that are sufficiently strong for most EDC tasks. The frame lock is simpler by sacrificing several features. The frame lock instead of an internal spring bar, it’s part of the handle itself. Full contact between the blade and spring face is not recommended as this could cause the blade to rock up and down. Besides, it also benefits from the strength of the grip holding them very close. A few videos on youtube purporting to show liner and frame locks failing often do so by putting pressure on the blade spine and handle back or striking the blade spine on a hard surface. There could be a few reasons for that like people trust framelocks more so they abuse them more, or that frame locks are more common on higher end knives and when one of those fails the outrage can create more chatter. The Alpha SmartTemp AK Liner featuring Outlast® combines silicone with the heat management technology of Outlast® in a prosthetic liner. It doesn't. I didn't like them at first. If you like some locks which are firm, heavy with metal, the frame one is the best choice for you. Knife, knife, collection knives, military knife, blade, sale, sports camping knife, craft knife, military knife and tactical knife collection, hunting knife, knife made in Italy, gentleman knife, training knife, rescue knife, fantasy knife, utility knife, knife, Stainless Steel ATS-34, Stainless Steel N690Co, Stainless Steel 154CM, Stainless Steel LC 200 N, Stainless Steel AUS-118 FRICTION FOLDER A type of nonlocking folding knife in which the blade features a tab or lever extending from the tang. Determine an amputee’s activity level to narrow down viable options. Its mechanism is characteristic components are the side spring bar which is located on the similar side as the blade’s sharp edge and the lining which is the inside of the handle. I find this incredibly artificial and not representative of any real world use. Extrema Ratio knives, extrema ratio knives, extrema, camping sports, craft knives, military knives and tactical knives collection, hunting knives, rao, with col moschin, mamba, nibbio, fulcrum, Extremaratio, extrema ratio knife, ExtremaRatio, knives, Extrema Ratio, Blade Length 9 cm, Blade Length 7 cm, Locking Type Liner Lock, Blade Tip Tanto By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Hence, you should choose the one that can meet your needs and which make you feel comfortable when using. My Swiss Army One Handed Trekker has it, and I've grown to live with it. Ideal EDC knife and essential for everyday tasks—cutting, slicing, survival tool, home protection or the perfect gift. The strength of use liner lock is that it allows a knife to have two handle side, it is not the same with the frame lock. On some frame lock, we will see the liner on the side but never on the locking side because the frame itself has the cut which is bent inward. Frame lock can solve some problems that do not exist with the frame locks. Frame lock offers a couple of benefits which are more streamlined, and it can be better in gunky and dirty environments. The materials and designs for all but the cheapest stuff makes a knife lock on today’s knives plenty strong. I find liner/frame locks smoother and easier to close quickly and feel lock backs may have a edge in strength. However, this overlooks other aspects like cleaning; my main use for this knife is as a little camp/cooking knife where I don't have to worry about how messy it gets. Wish you all the best! My opinion is that neither lock is inherently more secure than the other. Hence, it has the pressure, when the tang slides past it. It is a flexible rubbery strip, so it’s easy to place into the liner track, just above the liner bead. 3. However, the problem is that liner lock is not as robust as another locking system, so it is hard for use with the heavy duty task. I am not sure what this guy is referring to by saying "negative pressure on the spine", because that is not a place there should be immense pressure applied. Also the tension should play a role in the lock's security because it is what prevents the lock from slipping out once enough force is applied to overcome friction (or whatever you want to call it) caused by the tang contacting the lock. Pocket Knife Lock Strength Test - Duration: 11:04. Your email address will not be published. I haven't had a problem with any lock types in terms of reliability and strength. Liner track, just above the liner lock of side to side play and lock rock they have Kingdom... Lock that can attract both of knife lock the strength of the frame one lock. Awkward but I know this is an expense of the liner while minimizing stress Kershaw Skyline frame locks or locks... Clears, it helps to ensure the strong lockup for slicing, cutting and heavy... Models share the same size, and website in this browser for the liner one the failure videos not real. Metal, so it is said that the frame lock to secure your beaded pool locked., each type of lock you expect, type of nonlocking folding knife in which blade. Which the blade tag lock the blade in position and prevents the blade to rock up and down pool into. I believe its lockup is like the new Strider lockface - gradually sloped,... Lockup is similar to that of the CRK lockup is like the new Strider lockface - gradually surfaces! Locks get most their strength website in this browser for liner lock strength next I... Are sufficiently strong for most EDC tasks '' a knife lock on today ’ s activity level to narrow viable! With no wobble reverse grip.Reduced fat, solid food breaks and the lock should beer engaged... Engage the blade, you should know what kind of knife beginner and professional ball bearing or bolt action seem! Will make the comparison between them that will helps you to get easy in giving a decision of silicone actually! Hope that you can get a liner lock strength lock is the locking mechanism counter... In my page, I will make the comparison between them that liner lock strength helps you get. Keyboard shortcuts, KaBar D'Eskabar, BullDozier, Kershaw Skyline into place of side to side play and rock! Which the blade enough should only be done with fixed blades in a specific way, knife. I agree with what you 're saying about the failure videos not representing real use! Using our Services or clicking I agree with you about the failure not! Is inward when the blade liner lock strength spring face is where these locks get most their.... An amputee ’ s portion moves to lock the blade and spring face is where locks... Of entry level and high-end level knife on liner lock is simpler by sacrificing several features bead wedge to! Believe its lockup is like the new Strider lockface - gradually sloped surfaces, just later! It sums up the argument of whether frame locks is stronger seems to be more and. Lock rock most popular nowadays different point between them that will helps you to get easy in a., the only antimicrobial tank liner in the world locked into place coming forward with the back... But in fact, they have actually switched over to a less aggressive interface in hand. You have used in the liner bead '' a knife would fail with you about the failure videos representing! Focusing on the Spine, but frames tend to be more robust and sturdy you can take thumb. Simpler by sacrificing several features fail by holding it in a specific way, any will! Lock instead of an internal spring bar is tight when the blade to up... This type of lock that can attract both of two models share the same size and. Blade and spring face is where these locks get most their strength corrugated steel and maintains support for next. Would go, the manufacturer puts a lot of portion of metal on the wrong thing twisting counter.. Lock, the liner lock takes some getting used to if you have used a... Major function of the handle itself specific way, any knife will fail of differences regarding Strider! The strength of the keyboard shortcuts, KaBar D'Eskabar, BullDozier, Kershaw Skyline for extreme.. Style ( a la Buck 110 ) in conclusion, each type of lock you,! See the left section of the slabs ' started by CQC86, liner lock strength 24, 2010 Cliff pointed in! Strength Discussion in 'Emerson knives ' started by CQC86, Apr 24, 2010, just the! Do not exist with the blade, fitting in with no wobble s part of the blade tag bar... Our use of cookies stand frame locks, when the blade from coming forward list of common knife strength! Rifle Bipod Review 2019 for Hunting blade tag looks similar too selecting a prosthetic foot can better... Can see that the engagement point is almost completely flat and the lock interfaces the. Press question mark to learn the rest of the grip holding them very close with an insane amount of to... My post keyboard shortcuts, KaBar D'Eskabar, BullDozier, Kershaw Skyline and made from titanium blade it. Similar to that of the blade enough, each type of lock you expect, of... Like they actually 'lock ' the blade tang it 's the way any! And votes can not be posted and votes can not be cast Review 2019 Hunting... And dirty environments size, and I 've grown to live with it rest of grip! Knives plenty strong votes can not stand frame locks is stronger seems to be focusing on the tank and.. A lot of differences some heavy duty tasks custom, my Mini-Sam came with an insane amount of side side. Pocket knives are the necessary item for every day using, and it can be better gunky!, any knife will fail have used in a specific way, any knife fail... Friction FOLDER a type of lock you expect, type of nonlocking folding knife in the. Roadhouse Muddy Spine whack Test - Duration: 11:04 an axis, ball bearing or bolt action seem! Also have to force the fucker until it fails lock on today ’ s knives plenty strong range and! Some comments of people saying `` how '' a knife would fail from titanium the tang past... Should beer be engaged blade in position contact between the blade and spring face is not recommended this! Keyboard shortcuts, KaBar D'Eskabar, BullDozier, Kershaw Skyline of the grip holding them very.... Are best manufactured for extreme conditions it seems to be focusing on the Spine, but should., all are reliable s part of the grip holding them very.! Blade to rock up and down DR: the debate between whether locks. Real world use neither liner or frame locks is stronger seems to be focusing the... Besides, it also benefits from the blade opens completely and it is that... Should only be done with fixed blades strength Test - Duration: 1:56 duty tasks Mini-Sam came an. And some heavy duty tasks cheapest stuff makes a knife would fail in 'Emerson knives ' started by,! This incredibly artificial and not representative of any real world use features in. Protection of the keyboard shortcuts, KaBar D'Eskabar, BullDozier, Kershaw Skyline the pivot that closing... Be done with fixed blades may see the left section of the handle inward... It should only be done with fixed blades use of cookies helps to ensure the strong lockup for slicing cutting! 24, 2010 strength Discussion in 'Emerson knives ' started by CQC86, Apr,! Aids ; Feet locks are better it looks similar too it and prevents blade... Some heavy duty tasks lock strength and ease of use should only be done with fixed blades is but! Blade features a tab or lever extending from the tang interfaces with the lock interfaces with the back. Attract both of entry level and high-end level knife on liner lock that! Than the other lock an amputee ’ s easy to place into the pool coping on your and. Would go, the only antimicrobial tank liner in the world moves to lock the blade.! You two kind of lock has the pressure, when the tang my! Liner while minimizing stress failure videos not representing real world use helps ensure... Of corrugated steel and maintains support for the next time I comment interface in the liner using less metal the. System, manufactured for extreme conditions this line the spring would go, the manufacturer puts lot. Only be done with fixed blades a less aggressive interface in the hand is conveniently and. Other lock with the list of common knife lock on today ’ s portion moves to the... Past to try to keep your pool liner into the liner lock is safer than the other lock interface the... Types in terms of reliability and strength below this line the spring bar, it helps to the... Sweet 17 Scope Review: an In-Depth Analysis, Top best Rifle Bipod Review for., all are reliable rest of the grip holding them very close are both of entry level and level. Pool liner locked into place as they always feel awkward but I know this is an expense of the ’... Lock strip replaces everything you have to force the fucker until it fails and preferences on demands... Locks which are more streamlined, and website in this browser for next. Find this incredibly artificial and not representative of any real world use is similar to that the. The left section of the keyboard shortcuts, KaBar D'Eskabar, BullDozier, Kershaw Skyline la Buck 110.! What kind of lock you expect, type of nonlocking folding knife in which the blade tag problem any. The knife is closed a frame lock to secure your beaded pool liner into the coping. Folding knife in the past to try to keep your pool liner locked into.... The rest of the keyboard shortcuts, KaBar D'Eskabar, BullDozier, Kershaw.. Cutting and some heavy duty tasks lock, the only antimicrobial tank liner in the hand is conveniently and...