Because of this, pitchers, infielders, and fans are put in harm's way with little reaction time. Aluminum is lighter, and virtually impossible to break, on the other hand, if you go with wood, you could always nail screws in upside down to it, but then you might have a … Aluminum bats offer the same stiffness as that of a wooden bat. It is obvious that aluminum is solider than wood. Learn how physics make baseball possible with the Durham Bulls, NC company develops treatment for Covid-19, Telling apart COVID-19, allergies and the flu, Wearable health technology could aid in coronavirus effort. In the past few years, the construction of baseball bats has undergone numerous changes. Professional baseball hasn't adopted aluminum bats for a number of reasons, but mostly to preserve historical records that were achieved through player ability rather than bat technology. Transitioning from an aluminum bat to a wood bat can be very difficult. Wood bats vs Aluminum Discussion in 'Baseball' started by Braves, Dec 4, 2004. The aluminum also tends to "give" a little more than a wood bat when it comes in contact with the ball. Answers from trusted physicians on wood bat vs aluminum. are so important, the pros want to protect historic records. In my vast experience, I’ve come to appreciate the elegance and fine craftsmanship of Wooden Self-defense Bat(SDB). But there’s another interesting note with aluminum, says  George Manning, vice president of technical services at Hillerich & Bradsby Company. … wood bat vs aluminum bat. Owing to this, the ball comes off the bat with tremendous ease and the force generated can make the ball go farther than the maximum range of a wooden bat. Browser Not Supported. Call Us at 1-866-321-2287 for Assistance. The aluminum bat always wins the argument. But on the other hand, a broken wood bat would be good for stabbing your attacker in the face with. © 2000-2020 Pro Athlete, Inc. 10800 North Pomona Ave, Kansas City, MO 64153. With the sweet spot much smaller on a wood bat than aluminum, it forces the hitters to feel the barrel’s sweet spot more and helps the hitter focus on better mechanics and approach. Not only do wood bats have more to offer overall in terms of performance, but they also drive you to improve your fundamentals in the batter’s box. in many moves I've seen zombies eat through wood, and eat through doors. Braves Watauga Pioneers #6. So, in terms of head-to-head, aluminum bats are better than wood bats. Brain cancers are complex, aggressive and there are few treatment options. Or that the heavier the bat, the farther a young player will hit. Required fields are marked * Comment. It’s because aluminum bats are lighter that they can be swung faster. Wood vs. Aluminum Bats in High School. H&B manufactures the Louisville Slugger, what you could call America’s most famous bat. Manning calls the major difference between the two bats the “trampoline effect.” The walls of the aluminum bat are thin enough that they bend, or flex, when the ball hits the bat. The aluminum bat has a larger sweet spot and the power gained from increased bat speed. I will compare the average hitting distance of a wood and aluminum bat, how the bat feels, and how far the ball goes then compare the two bats … Do you have a preference? Because an aluminum bat has a hollow barrel and a solid handle, its CM shifts closer to the handle. Please upgrade to a supported browser: Answer a few simple questions to find your perfect bat. Braves Watauga Pioneers #6. Both, aluminum and wooden bats have a sweet spot, but the sweet spot of the metal alloy bat is larger than that of its wooden counterpart. Anonymous. A down side of using an aluminum bat is that it may cost up to 10 times more than the wood bat equivalent. In this project I will take the scientific approach to answer this question. to keep your timing down. Mix and match eligible items for extra savings! Most players, parents and coaches feel that a $250.00 aluminum bat will take their son/daughter all the way to the majors. When it comes to self-defense, specialists agree that an aluminum bat has more benefits over a wooden bat. Frank Graff talks about differences in wood vs. aluminum baseball bats that affect personal average and the game itself. Aside from the effectiveness of the bat, there are other differences. The weight is also distributed much differently in a wood bat vs. aluminum. Wood bats can have drops of -1 or -2 (30 ounces minus 31 or 32 inches). Some metals have already been prohibited from being used in bats because the ball was hit too hard. Which is better? It’s because aluminum bats are lighter that they can be swung faster. But there’s another interesting note with aluminum, says  George Manning, vice president of technical services at Hillerich & Bradsby Company. Want to put up great statistics? And, as you can see, both bat types have their advantages. for zombie bashing? While composite bats are a lot more durable than wood bats, they are much less durable when compared to aluminum bats. Aluminum bats also have bigger barrels and a bigger sweet spot, which the space of the bat where you can actually hit the baseball. A down side of using an aluminum bat is that it may cost up to 10 times more than the wood bat equivalent. In the end, aluminum bats provide more power, a faster swing, and a larger sweet spot. So, I dunno, it's a toss up. Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 Next > Dec 4, 2004 at 8:31 AM #1. Aluminum vs Wooden Bats. Leave a Reply Cancel reply. Wood bat vs. Aluminum bat? Page 3 of 3 < Prev 1 2 3. First: Carpenters sometimes become allergic to sawdust - typically if they frequently work with exotic woods. That's because in 1974, after a few years in which bats made from tubes of aluminum started to appear, the NCAA approved the use of aluminum bats. They are about five ounces lighter than wooden bats and the barrels are bigger. The “smack” of a hockey stick hitting the puck in the stick’s sweet spot. Use an aluminum bat. An aluminum bat is also more forgiving and unlikely to break when not hit in the sweet part of the bat. Make sure you gun is loaded, though, and clean it regularly. While there is no doubt the sound is different, what about bat performance in the game? Aluminum bats started to appear in the 1970s. But, the metal made the bat more durable and, in turn, cheaper. Safer: Sure, wood bats can shatter, but aluminum bats increase the velocity of the ball off the bat tremendously. Which is better?In youth baseball today the aluminum bat is made out to be a miracle stick. When it comes to their construction, composite barreled bats come as either one-piece or two-piece bats. The first real baseball bat was created in 1884 and it took 90 years before the next major change to baseball bats: aluminum. I would like to cover the issue of wood versus aluminum bats. It is about bat speed but you may throw you timing off by using wood exclusively. 1 0. The NCAA is also taking a closer look at bat design to slow down the bat speed. There’s no doubt the debate over tradition and technology will continue. 1 decade ago. Alternate your practice sets (one set of 10 swings with wood, next with aluminum, etc.) What advantages or disadvantages have you seen? There are some sounds in sports that are simply iconic. Think of the “thwack” sound of a perfectly hit golf ball. A doctor at UNC Medical Center is using genomic sequencing to identify genetic mutations that might be driving a patient’s tumor. Looking to make the Pros? If you have any wood bat or aluminum bat related questions, give our Pros a call at 1-(866)-321-2287. Homerun totals increased and batting averages sky rocketed. Composite bats, on the other hand, are lighter than wood. As demand for aluminum bats steadily increased throughout the 1980s and into the 1990s, so too did the technology. related questions, give our Pros a call at 1-(866)-321-2287. first real baseball bat was created in 1884. Aluminum bats started to appear in the 1970s. makes the player a better hitter. So, what are the differences and advantages between wood bats and aluminum bats? Post navigation. Most players, parents and coaches feel that a $250.00 aluminum bat will take their son/daughter all the way to the majors. Wooden Bats Is baseball America’s pastime? Posts: 14,703 Likes Received: 0 Joined: Jan 7, 2003. ss-05 said: . Aluminum Bats vs. Posts: 14,703 Likes Received: 0 Joined: Jan 7, 2003. The introduction of high dollared aluminum bats produce football like scores, higher statistics, and a … The only major difference we may find would be their weight. What do you think? The debate doesn’t end at just wood and aluminum, though. I will describe that procedure, then estimate the margin by As compared to the wood bat, when player contact with the aluminum bat, the aluminum absorbs the energy from the ball and sends it back, giving it a higher ‘trampoline effect.’ This creates more force behind the ball. An aluminum bat can last for years, while wood bats can shatter the first time they strike a ball. By knowing the mutation, the doctor can create a treatment plan that targets the mutation. See our recommendation for aluminum bats: Aluminum bats often have drops of -3 (30 ounces minus 33 inches, for example). In youth baseball today the aluminum bat is made out to be a miracle stick. New rule adoption, such as BBCOR, in some Leagues limit the dangers aluminum bats can have by imitating wooden bat characteristics. Frank Graff is a producer/reporter with UNC-TV, focusing on Sci Tech Now North Carolina, a weekly science series that airs Tuesdays on UNC-TV. An aluminum bat is much lighter than a wooden bat, which increases swing speeds and allows to hit the ball a greater distance. Why? What is better a wood or aluminum bat? Jump to Latest Follow 1 - 20 of 43 Posts. Notify me of new posts by email. PS most high schools still use non-wood to keep costs of bat purchases at a minimum. Use a wood bat. Dec 6, 2004 at 2:35 PM #21. Relevance. Another key difference is the location of a bat's center of mass (CM), or balance point. All rights reserved. One downside to an aluminum bat is the more you use it, the more damage you are doing to it, and for the purists out there, it isn’t traditional. Aluminum Bat vs. Wood Bat. Name * Email * Website. Then the sound of bat striking ball is more of a dull clang. The pros also want to show that athletic performance in the game is due to human ability and not bat technology. There is also a legitimate concern about player safety because the ball is travelling so much faster. Aluminum bats were simply a metal version of a wood bat. The aluminum vs. composite debate is just as fierce. Anonymous. As such, the bat handle is very strong and will not break. Answer Save. The law was passed to cut down on injuries from the ball bouncing off the aluminum bat at a high rate of speed. Aluminum bats are hollow, except near the handle end, so they tend to be lighter and swing faster than a solid wood bat of the same length. Do you know about the new youth baseball bat standard that takes effect on January 1, 2018? It's less likely to break than wood. In the yesteryears, solid wood bats were the preferred choice of material for the development of baseball bats. Wood bats give a hitter much tighter “feedback” on their swing. Aluminum is much stronger than ash wood, and the handle of an aluminum bat is a thin cylindrical tube with reasonably thick walls (thicker than the barrel portion). The change was subtle, at first. Brain cancers are complex, aggressive and there are few treatment options. However, coaches, instructors, Wooden bats, for example, are more likely to break upon impact with a ball near the middle of the bat (Russel, 2003). Both bats have advantages, and we can compare the qualities of the two designs first. More common woods like oak and pine generally don't induce respiratory allergies. In addition to producing these special segments, Frank will provide additional information related to his stories through this North Carolina Science Now Reporter's Blog! You can try reloading the page by clicking here. Favorite Answer. Many Leagues have taken steps to reduce the risk and protect players with rule changes (BBCOR, 2018 rule change link). Notify me of follow-up comments by email. That’s because the bats are aluminum. Your email address will not be published. However, when it comes to the weight, aluminum bats tend to be way heavier. And of course, you can’t beat the sound of the crack of a baseball bat on the ball. That is, unless, the sport is little league baseball, NCAA men’s baseball or women’s softball. We apologize for the inconvenience, but something went wrong with this page. The ball travels farther. Manning says when the company began comparing statistics between wooden and aluminum bats, it found team batting averages went up about 20-points and home run production almost doubled for teams with aluminum bats. That’s the primary reason professional baseball is sticking with wooden bats. Aluminum bat would make more sense. A conversation with RTI International researcher Robert Furberg about how technology like Fitbits and smart watches can... Bone-jarring tackles almost always make the highlight reel in a National Football League game. 1 decade ago. Contact reactions to wood are exceedingly rare. A doctor at UNC Medical Center is using... A potential new treatment of Covid-19 patients is being developed in Clayton, North Carolina. Here are some of the reasons why: Durability. But because the walls of the bat are thin enough that they bend or flex when the ball hits the bat, the energy is then given back to the ball when the wall bounces back. An aluminum bat is also more forgiving and unlikely to break when not hit in the sweet part of the bat. An aluminum baseball bat is a good back up in case your gun misfires. For the major leaguers maybe, but for college athletes it seems more like a new age video game. They are about five ounces lighter than wooden bats and the barrels are bigger. In a game where statistics such as batting averages, slugging percentages, etc. They also offer a sturdier and a lighter height of swing. Wood vs. Aluminum Bats and the NCAA Test Protocol Alan M. Nathan Originally written, January 10, 2003 Revised, April 15, 2007 I will focus my remarks entirely around the procedure used by the NCAA to control the performance of non-wood bats. Wood vs Aluminum Bats New York City just passed a new law that bans the use of aluminum bats in all baseball games that is under the age of 18. Wood bats provide hitters with better mechanics, better approach, better contact and Transitioning from an aluminum bat to a wood bat can be very difficult. I would like to cover the issue of wood versus aluminum bats. The major question to judge the difference between aluminum and wood bats is – can an aluminum bat hit a baseball farther than a wooden bat? 1; 2; 3; Next. Therefore, it goes that an aluminum bat suffers little wear and tear over the years. Wood bats vs Aluminum Discussion in 'Baseball' started by Braves, Dec 4, 2004. Also, aluminum bats have received criticism for being dangerous. Composite Bats vs Aluminum Bats. 703 Words 3 Pages. and serious players should use wood bats, even if it's just for training or practice. The Black Box Around Black HolesNovember 6, 2014In many ways, theoretical physics is the field closest to the old-... UNC-TV 10 UNC-TV Drive PO Box 14900Research Triangle Park, NC  27709-4900Â, UNC-TV e-GuideUNC-TV on FacebookUNC-TV on InstagramUNC-TV Rootle FacebookUNC-TV on Twitter UNC-TV on YouTubeMore UNC-TV Video, About UsPressroomEmploymentInternshipsDirectionsContact UsWhat's On, Donate NowMembership LevelsCorporate & FoundationSustained Giving Estate PlanningMatching GiftsDonate a CarVolunteer, Reports and ComplianceUNC-TV DMCA Agent Donor Bill of Rights Annual EEO ReportClosed Captioning Contact  FCC Public FilePublic File Contact, © 2020 UNC-TV and its licensors. The barrel, where the walls are thinner, may dent - or even crack if the walls are too thin, the but bat will not break. Now, aluminum bats are used in Little League, softball, college baseball, and high school. It uses antibodies... How to tell the difference between COVID-19, allergies and the flu. 14 Answers. While some of the energy from the collision is transferred into the ball and lost to heat, there is much more energy transferred into the bat. The wood bat was replaced by aluminum which is presently being replaced by composite bats. Something to discuss during the seventh inning stretch perhaps? —Frank GraffÂ. A typical aluminum bat has less weight in the barrel than a typical wood bat and is therefore less effective (Nathan, 2002).